Skip to content
Savvy Collecting Savvy Collecting
Football

Buffalo Bills — 2023 Legacy Checklist

Browse by team or search a player, card number, or set. Use Autos and SSPs to narrow the checklist.

Product overview & checklist counts

The Buffalo Bills have 24 unique cards in 2023 Legacy Football across 11 players. Jim Kelly leads the team with 4 cards, followed by Josh Allen with 4. The Bills checklist includes 5 autograph subjects, 3 rookies, and cards from 103 distinct card sets.

Buffalo Bills Overview

The 2023 Legacy Buffalo Bills checklist tracked on Savvy Collecting spans 24 unique cards (parallels collapsed), 11 players, 4 rookie cards, and 6 autographs. Below you'll find every Buffalo Bills player, their rookie cards, autographs, and short prints (SSPs) — plus the complete card-by-card checklist for the team.

Notable Buffalo Bills autograph signers in 2023 Legacy include Dalton Kincaid, Bruce Smith, Dalton Kincaid/Michael Mayer, Jim Kelly, and Thurman Thomas. Filter the checklist to autographs to see every signed Buffalo Bills card.

The most-collected Buffalo Bills players in this product are Jim Kelly, Josh Allen, Stefon Diggs, Thurman Thomas, and Andre Reed. Open any player to see their full card list, or use the player comparison tool to weigh two Buffalo Bills players side by side.

24Unique Cards
198Cards
11Players
4Rookie Cards
6Autographs
103Card Sets
When both are active, shows cards with autographs or SSP versions. –
About filters & checklist counts

Choose a team or school to browse its cards. All Cards groups cards by family. Counts show unique card identities with parallels collapsed; shared cards count once in product totals.

Buffalo Bills 24

24 unique cards · 198 appearances including parallels Team page →

Andre Reed

2 unique cards · 8 versions
  • 1 Andre ReedBuffalo Bills Decade of Dominance · Decade of Dominance Indigo
  • 2 Andre ReedBuffalo Bills Hall of Fame Dare to Tear

Ben Roethlisberger/Josh Allen/Will Levis

1 unique card · 1 version
  • 10 Ben Roethlisberger/Josh Allen/Will LevisBuffalo Bills · Pittsburgh Steelers · Tennessee Titans Past Present and Future Dare to Tear

Bruce Smith

2 unique cards · 18 versions
  • 9 Bruce SmithBuffalo Bills For the Ages · For the Ages Indigo
  • 105 Bruce SmithBuffalo Bills Legends Includes Auto

Dalton Kincaid

2 unique cards · 12 versions
  • 5 Dalton KincaidBuffalo Bills Futures Dual Patch Autographs Includes Auto
  • 11 Dalton KincaidBuffalo Bills Futures Patch Autographs Includes Auto

Dalton Kincaid/Michael Mayer

1 unique card · 6 versions
  • 3 Dalton Kincaid/Michael MayerBuffalo Bills · Las Vegas Raiders Futures Ink Combos Includes Auto

Jim Kelly

4 unique cards · 20 versions
  • 9 Jim KellyBuffalo Bills Blast from the Past · Blast from the Past Indigo
  • 12 Jim KellyBuffalo Bills Hall of Fame Dare to Tear
  • 11 Jim KellyBuffalo Bills HoloGraphs
  • 122 Jim KellyBuffalo Bills Legends Includes Auto

Josh Allen

4 unique cards · 47 versions
  • 10 Josh AllenBuffalo Bills Base
  • 4 Josh AllenBuffalo Bills Main Attractions
  • 29 Josh AllenBuffalo Bills Under the Lights
  • 12 Josh AllenBuffalo Bills Veteran Dare to Tear

Stefon Diggs

3 unique cards · 45 versions
  • 11 Stefon DiggsBuffalo Bills Base
  • 1 Stefon DiggsBuffalo Bills Dreamcatchers
  • 37 Stefon DiggsBuffalo Bills Under the Lights

Thurman Thomas

3 unique cards · 19 versions
  • 13 Thurman ThomasBuffalo Bills Blast from the Past · Blast from the Past Indigo
  • 28 Thurman ThomasBuffalo Bills HoloGraphs
  • 146 Thurman ThomasBuffalo Bills Legends Includes Auto

Von Miller

1 unique card · 21 versions
  • 12 Von MillerBuffalo Bills Base

Willis McGahee

1 unique card · 1 version
  • 12 Willis McGaheeBuffalo Bills Gridiron Greats

Buffalo Bills Rookies

Dalton Kincaid 2 Ben Roethlisberger/Josh Allen/Will Levis 1 Dalton Kincaid/Michael Mayer 1

Autograph Signers

Dalton Kincaid 2 Bruce Smith 1 Dalton Kincaid/Michael Mayer 1 Jim Kelly 1 Thurman Thomas 1

Featured Buffalo Bills Players

Jim Kelly 4 Josh Allen 4 Stefon Diggs 3 Thurman Thomas 3 Andre Reed 2 Bruce Smith 2 Dalton Kincaid 2 Ben Roethlisberger/Josh Allen/Will Levis 1 Dalton Kincaid/Michael Mayer 1 Von Miller 1 Willis McGahee 1

Top Buffalo Bills SSPs & Case Hits

Filter this team to SSPs to surface its short prints and case hits.

Complete Buffalo Bills Checklist

The full card-by-card Buffalo Bills checklist for 2023 Legacy is listed above — every player, set, parallel, and short print. Switch to All Cards for a flat, filterable list.

View Buffalo Bills checklist ↑ Compare Buffalo Bills players →

Buffalo Bills FAQ

How many Buffalo Bills cards are in 2023 Legacy?

Savvy Collecting tracks 24 unique Buffalo Bills cards (parallels collapsed) across 11 players in the 2023 Legacy checklist, including base cards, inserts, parallels, short prints, and autographs.

How many Buffalo Bills rookie cards are in 2023 Legacy?

There are 4 Buffalo Bills rookie cards in the 2023 Legacy checklist tracked here, highlighted in purple.

Which Buffalo Bills players have autographs in 2023 Legacy?

Buffalo Bills autograph signers include Dalton Kincaid, Bruce Smith, Dalton Kincaid/Michael Mayer, Jim Kelly, and Thurman Thomas. Filter the team to autographs to see every signed card.

How do I compare Buffalo Bills players?

Use the Compare Players tool to line up any two players side by side across products and years — checklist depth, autographs, and short prints — to judge break value.