Skip to content
Savvy Collecting Savvy Collecting
Football

Indianapolis Colts — 2023 National Treasures Checklist

Browse by team or search a player, card number, or set. Use Autos and SSPs to narrow the checklist.

Product overview & checklist counts

The Indianapolis Colts have 77 unique cards in 2023 National Treasures Football across 34 players. Anthony Richardson leads the team with 9 cards, followed by Josh Downs with 9. The Colts checklist includes 13 autograph subjects, 11 rookies, and cards from 298 distinct card sets.

Indianapolis Colts Overview

The 2023 National Treasures Indianapolis Colts checklist tracked on Savvy Collecting spans 77 unique cards (parallels collapsed), 34 players, 29 rookie cards, and 32 autographs. Below you'll find every Indianapolis Colts player, their rookie cards, autographs, and short prints (SSPs) — plus the complete card-by-card checklist for the team.

Notable Indianapolis Colts autograph signers in 2023 National Treasures include Anthony Richardson, Josh Downs, Peyton Manning, Alec Pierce, and Reggie Wayne. Filter the checklist to autographs to see every signed Indianapolis Colts card.

The most-collected Indianapolis Colts players in this product are Anthony Richardson, Josh Downs, Peyton Manning, Jonathan Taylor, and Michael Pittman Jr.. Open any player to see their full card list, or use the player comparison tool to weigh two Indianapolis Colts players side by side.

77Unique Cards
491Cards
34Players
29Rookie Cards
32Autographs
298Card Sets
When both are active, shows cards with autographs or SSP versions. –
About filters & checklist counts

Choose a team or school to browse its cards. All Cards groups cards by family. Counts show unique card identities with parallels collapsed; shared cards count once in product totals.

Indianapolis Colts 77

77 unique cards · 491 appearances including parallels Team page →

Aaron Rodgers/Breece Hall/Davante Adams/Derrick Henry/Garrett Wilson/Isiah Pacheco/Ja'Marr Chase/James Cook/Joe Burrow/Josh Allen/Josh Jacobs/Justin Herbert/Keenan Allen/Lamar Jackson/Nico Collins/Odell Beckham Jr./Patrick Mahomes II/Raheem Mostert/Stefon Diggs/Travis Etienne Jr./Trevor Lawrence/Tua Tagovailoa/Tyreek Hill/Zack Moss

1 unique card · 2 versions
  • 3 Aaron Rodgers/Breece Hall/Davante Adams/Derrick Henry/Garrett Wilson/Isiah Pacheco/Ja'Marr Chase/James Cook/Joe Burrow/Josh Allen/Josh Jacobs/Justin Herbert/Keenan Allen/Lamar Jackson/Nico Collins/Odell Beckham Jr./Patrick Mahomes II/Raheem Mostert/Stefon Diggs/Travis Etienne Jr./Trevor Lawrence/Tua Tagovailoa/Tyreek Hill/Zack MossBaltimore Ravens · Buffalo Bills · Cincinnati Bengals · Houston Texans · Indianapolis Colts · Jacksonville Jaguars · Kansas City Chiefs · Las Vegas Raiders · Los Angeles Chargers · Miami Dolphins · New York Jets · Tennessee Titans Treasure Chest Tags · Treasure Chest Prime

Adam Vinatieri

1 unique card · 5 versions
  • 9 Adam VinatieriIndianapolis Colts Treasured Moments Includes Auto

Adam Vinatieri/Alan Faneca/Dallas Clark/Hines Ward/Jeff Saturday/Jerome Bettis/Mike Vrabel/Peyton Manning/Reggie Wayne/Tedy Bruschi/Troy Polamalu/Ty Law

1 unique card · 2 versions
  • 2 Adam Vinatieri/Alan Faneca/Dallas Clark/Hines Ward/Jeff Saturday/Jerome Bettis/Mike Vrabel/Peyton Manning/Reggie Wayne/Tedy Bruschi/Troy Polamalu/Ty LawIndianapolis Colts · New England Patriots · Pittsburgh Steelers Treasure Chest Signatures · Treasure Chest Signatures Platinum Includes Auto

Aidan O'Connell/Anthony Richardson

1 unique card · 2 versions
  • 15 Aidan O'Connell/Anthony RichardsonIndianapolis Colts · Las Vegas Raiders Rookie Prime Pairings · Rookie Prime Pairings Platinum

Aidan O'Connell/Anthony Richardson/Bijan Robinson/Bryce Young/C.J. Stroud/Chris Rodriguez Jr./De'Von Achane/Deuce Vaughn/Dorian Thompson-Robinson/Jahmyr Gibbs/Jaren Hall/Jaxon Smith-Njigba/Jordan Addison/Josh Downs/Marvin Mims/Puka Nacua/Quentin Johnston/Roschon Johnson/Sean Clifford/Tank Dell/Tyjae Spears/Will Levis/Zach Charbonnet/Zay Flowers

1 unique card · 3 versions
  • 1 Aidan O'Connell/Anthony Richardson/Bijan Robinson/Bryce Young/C.J. Stroud/Chris Rodriguez Jr./De'Von Achane/Deuce Vaughn/Dorian Thompson-Robinson/Jahmyr Gibbs/Jaren Hall/Jaxon Smith-Njigba/Jordan Addison/Josh Downs/Marvin Mims/Puka Nacua/Quentin Johnston/Roschon Johnson/Sean Clifford/Tank Dell/Tyjae Spears/Will Levis/Zach Charbonnet/Zay FlowersAtlanta Falcons · Baltimore Ravens · Carolina Panthers · Chicago Bears · Cleveland Browns · Dallas Cowboys · Denver Broncos · Detroit Lions · Green Bay Packers · Houston Texans · Indianapolis Colts · Las Vegas Raiders · Los Angeles Chargers · Los Angeles Rams · Miami Dolphins · Minnesota Vikings · Seattle Seahawks · Tennessee Titans · Washington Commanders Treasure Chest · Treasure Chest Tags · Treasure Chest Prime

Alec Pierce

3 unique cards · 15 versions
  • 6 Alec PierceIndianapolis Colts 2022 Playoff National Treasures Football - Rookie Patch Autographs Stars and Stripes Blue Includes Auto
  • 1 Alec PierceIndianapolis Colts 2022 Playoff National Treasures Football - Rookie Patch Autographs Stars and Stripes Holo Silver Includes Auto
  • 39 Alec PierceIndianapolis Colts Signatures Includes Auto

Anthony Richardson

9 unique cards · 129 versions
  • 7 Anthony RichardsonIndianapolis Colts American Treasures Autographs Booklet Includes Auto
  • 21 Anthony RichardsonIndianapolis Colts Colossal Materials
  • 4 Anthony RichardsonIndianapolis Colts Gladiators Includes Auto
  • 1 Anthony RichardsonIndianapolis Colts Heirlooms Includes Auto
  • 35 Anthony RichardsonIndianapolis Colts Old Glory Signature Includes Auto
  • 2 Anthony RichardsonIndianapolis Colts Rookie Dual Materials Includes Auto
  • 157 Anthony RichardsonIndianapolis Colts Rookie Patch Autographs Includes Auto
  • 18 Anthony RichardsonIndianapolis Colts Treasure Hunt · Treasure Hunt Platinum
  • 2 Anthony RichardsonIndianapolis Colts Treasured Rookies Includes Auto

Anthony Richardson/Bijan Robinson/Devon Witherspoon/Jahmyr Gibbs/Jaxon Smith-Njigba/Puka Nacua/Rashee Rice/Tommy DeVito/Tyson Bagent

1 unique card · 2 versions
  • 2 Anthony Richardson/Bijan Robinson/Devon Witherspoon/Jahmyr Gibbs/Jaxon Smith-Njigba/Puka Nacua/Rashee Rice/Tommy DeVito/Tyson BagentAtlanta Falcons · Chicago Bears · Detroit Lions · Indianapolis Colts · Kansas City Chiefs · Los Angeles Rams · New York Giants · Seattle Seahawks Treasured Signatures · Treasured Signatures Platinum Includes Auto

Anthony Richardson/Bijan Robinson/Jordan Addison

1 unique card · 5 versions
  • 1 Anthony Richardson/Bijan Robinson/Jordan AddisonAtlanta Falcons · Indianapolis Colts · Minnesota Vikings Rookie Triple Booklet

Anthony Richardson/Bryce Young/C.J. Stroud/Will Levis

1 unique card · 6 versions
  • 1 Anthony Richardson/Bryce Young/C.J. Stroud/Will LevisCarolina Panthers · Houston Texans · Indianapolis Colts · Tennessee Titans NFL Gear Quad Materials

Anthony Richardson/C.J. Stroud

2 unique cards · 7 versions
  • 2 Anthony Richardson/C.J. StroudHouston Texans · Indianapolis Colts NFL Shields Dual
  • 28 Anthony Richardson/C.J. StroudHouston Texans · Indianapolis Colts Rookie NFL Gear Combo Materials

Anthony Richardson/Josh Downs

2 unique cards · 8 versions
  • 1 Anthony Richardson/Josh DownsIndianapolis Colts Rookie NFL Gear Combo Materials
  • 8 Anthony Richardson/Josh DownsIndianapolis Colts Rookie Prime Pairings · Rookie Prime Pairings Platinum

Bubba Smith

1 unique card · 1 version
  • 3 Bubba SmithIndianapolis Colts Treasured Cuts

DeForest Buckner

1 unique card · 4 versions
  • 6 DeForest BucknerIndianapolis Colts NFL Game Gear · NFL Game Gear Prime Holo · NFL Game Gear Super Prime

Edgerrin James

1 unique card · 1 version
  • 10 Edgerrin JamesIndianapolis Colts Spectra HOF Signatures Includes Auto

Evan Hull

1 unique card · 12 versions
  • 124 Evan HullIndianapolis Colts Rookie Signatures Includes Auto

Frank Gore

1 unique card · 2 versions
  • 8 Frank GoreIndianapolis Colts Gridiron Graphs · Gridiron Graphs Platinum

Gardner Minshew II

1 unique card · 6 versions
  • 18 Gardner Minshew IIIndianapolis Colts Tremendous Treasures

Gardner Minshew II/Zack Moss

1 unique card · 4 versions
  • 12 Gardner Minshew II/Zack MossIndianapolis Colts NFL Gear Combo Materials · NFL Gear Combo Materials Holo · NFL Gear Combo Materials Laundry Tags

Jaxon Smith-Njigba/Josh Downs

1 unique card · 1 version
  • 8 Jaxon Smith-Njigba/Josh DownsIndianapolis Colts · Seattle Seahawks NFL Shields Dual

Jeff Saturday

2 unique cards · 13 versions
  • 27 Jeff SaturdayIndianapolis Colts Framed Fabric · Framed Fabric Holo · Framed Fabric Platinum
  • 49 Jeff SaturdayIndianapolis Colts Lasting Legacies

Jerry Rice/Art Monk/Cris Carter/Isaac Bruce/Michael Irvin/Randy Moss/Reggie Wayne/Steve Largent/Tim Brown

1 unique card · 2 versions
  • 1 Jerry Rice/Art Monk/Cris Carter/Isaac Bruce/Michael Irvin/Randy Moss/Reggie Wayne/Steve Largent/Tim BrownDallas Cowboys · Indianapolis Colts · Las Vegas Raiders · Los Angeles Rams · Minnesota Vikings · San Francisco 49ers · Seattle Seahawks · Washington Commanders Treasured Signatures · Treasured Signatures Platinum Includes Auto

Jim Harbaugh

1 unique card · 8 versions
  • 14 Jim HarbaughIndianapolis Colts Lasting Legacies Holo

Joe Burrow/Aaron Rodgers/Breece Hall/Davante Adams/Derrick Henry/Garrett Wilson/Isiah Pacheco/Ja'Marr Chase/James Cook/Josh Allen/Josh Jacobs/Justin Herbert/Keenan Allen/Lamar Jackson/Nico Collins/Odell Beckham Jr./Patrick Mahomes II/Raheem Mostert/Stefon Diggs/Travis Etienne Jr./Trevor Lawrence/Tua Tagovailoa/Tyreek Hill/Zack Moss

1 unique card · 1 version
  • 3 Joe Burrow/Aaron Rodgers/Breece Hall/Davante Adams/Derrick Henry/Garrett Wilson/Isiah Pacheco/Ja'Marr Chase/James Cook/Josh Allen/Josh Jacobs/Justin Herbert/Keenan Allen/Lamar Jackson/Nico Collins/Odell Beckham Jr./Patrick Mahomes II/Raheem Mostert/Stefon Diggs/Travis Etienne Jr./Trevor Lawrence/Tua Tagovailoa/Tyreek Hill/Zack MossBaltimore Ravens · Buffalo Bills · Cincinnati Bengals · Houston Texans · Indianapolis Colts · Jacksonville Jaguars · Kansas City Chiefs · Las Vegas Raiders · Los Angeles Chargers · Miami Dolphins · New York Jets · Tennessee Titans Treasure Chest

Jonathan Taylor

7 unique cards · 47 versions
  • 7 Jonathan TaylorIndianapolis Colts 2022 Playoff National Treasures Football - Colossal Signatures Includes Auto
  • 3 Jonathan TaylorIndianapolis Colts 2022 Playoff National Treasures Football - Gridiron Graphs
  • 5 Jonathan TaylorIndianapolis Colts 2022 Playoff National Treasures Football - Virtuoso · 2022 Playoff National Treasures Football - All-Pro Signatures Includes Auto
  • 41 Jonathan TaylorIndianapolis Colts Base
  • 52 Jonathan TaylorIndianapolis Colts Century Materials
  • 13 Jonathan TaylorIndianapolis Colts The Future · The Future Holo Silver · The Future Black Platinum
  • 25 Jonathan TaylorIndianapolis Colts Tremendous Treasures

Jonathan Taylor/Zack Moss

1 unique card · 1 version
  • 26 Jonathan Taylor/Zack MossIndianapolis Colts NFL Shields Dual

Josh Downs

9 unique cards · 68 versions
  • 12 Josh DownsIndianapolis Colts Heirlooms
  • 21 Josh DownsIndianapolis Colts Rookie Dual Materials
  • 26 Josh DownsIndianapolis Colts Rookie Hats Off Signatures New Era Includes Auto
  • 17 Josh DownsIndianapolis Colts Rookie Material Signatures RPS Includes Auto
  • 18 Josh DownsIndianapolis Colts Rookie NFL Gear Signature Combos Includes Auto
  • 175 Josh DownsIndianapolis Colts Rookie Patch Autographs Includes Auto
  • 177 Josh DownsIndianapolis Colts Rookie Patch Autographs Midnight Includes Auto
  • 14 Josh DownsIndianapolis Colts Rookie Treasures Blue
  • 27 Josh DownsIndianapolis Colts Tremendous Treasures Rookies

Lenny Moore

1 unique card · 4 versions
  • 28 Lenny MooreIndianapolis Colts Treasures of the Hall · Treasures of the Hall Holo · Treasures of the Hall Platinum

Marshall Faulk

1 unique card · 4 versions
  • 36 Marshall FaulkIndianapolis Colts Heirlooms · Heirlooms Holo · Heirlooms Platinum

Michael Pittman Jr.

5 unique cards · 33 versions
  • 42 Michael Pittman Jr.Indianapolis Colts Base
  • 74 Michael Pittman Jr.Indianapolis Colts Century Materials
  • 44 Michael Pittman Jr.Indianapolis Colts Framed Fabric · Framed Fabric Holo · Framed Fabric Platinum
  • 53 Michael Pittman Jr.Indianapolis Colts NFL Shields
  • 56 Michael Pittman Jr.Indianapolis Colts Treasured Patches · Treasured Patches Holo · Treasured Patches Platinum

Peyton Manning

8 unique cards · 53 versions
  • 43 Peyton ManningIndianapolis Colts Base
  • 6 Peyton ManningIndianapolis Colts Colossal Signatures Holo Silver Includes Auto
  • 24 Peyton ManningIndianapolis Colts Gladiators Includes Auto
  • 50 Peyton ManningIndianapolis Colts Lasting Legacies Holo
  • 17 Peyton ManningIndianapolis Colts Material Treasures Signatures Holo Silver Includes Auto
  • 8 Peyton ManningIndianapolis Colts Notable Nicknames
  • 40 Peyton ManningIndianapolis Colts Signatures Includes Auto
  • 2 Peyton ManningDenver Broncos · Indianapolis Colts Virtuoso · Super Bowl Signatures · Spectra HOF Signatures

Peyton Manning/Reggie Wayne

2 unique cards · 2 versions
  • 6 Peyton Manning/Reggie WayneIndianapolis Colts 2022 Playoff National Treasures Football - Synced Signatures Includes Auto
  • 5 Peyton Manning/Reggie WayneIndianapolis Colts Synced Signatures Includes Auto

Reggie Wayne

5 unique cards · 37 versions
  • 4 Reggie WayneIndianapolis Colts All-Pro Signatures Includes Auto
  • 44 Reggie WayneIndianapolis Colts Base
  • 22 Reggie WayneIndianapolis Colts Colossal Signatures Includes Auto
  • 42 Reggie WayneIndianapolis Colts Heirlooms · Heirlooms Holo · Heirlooms Platinum
  • 38 Reggie WayneIndianapolis Colts Signatures Includes Auto

Vince Lombardi/Peyton Manning

1 unique card · 1 version
  • 1 Vince Lombardi/Peyton ManningGreen Bay Packers · Indianapolis Colts Treasured Dual Cuts

Indianapolis Colts Rookies

Anthony Richardson 9 Josh Downs 9 Anthony Richardson/C.J. Stroud 2 Anthony Richardson/Josh Downs 2 Aidan O'Connell/Anthony Richardson 1 Aidan O'Connell/Anthony Richardson/Bijan Robinson/Bryce Young/C.J. Stroud/Chris Rodriguez Jr./De'Von Achane/Deuce Vaughn/Dorian Thompson-Robinson/Jahmyr Gibbs/Jaren Hall/Jaxon Smith-Njigba/Jordan Addison/Josh Downs/Marvin Mims/Puka Nacua/Quentin Johnston/Roschon Johnson/Sean Clifford/Tank Dell/Tyjae Spears/Will Levis/Zach Charbonnet/Zay Flowers 1 Anthony Richardson/Bijan Robinson/Devon Witherspoon/Jahmyr Gibbs/Jaxon Smith-Njigba/Puka Nacua/Rashee Rice/Tommy DeVito/Tyson Bagent 1 Anthony Richardson/Bijan Robinson/Jordan Addison 1 Anthony Richardson/Bryce Young/C.J. Stroud/Will Levis 1 Evan Hull 1 Jaxon Smith-Njigba/Josh Downs 1

Autograph Signers

Anthony Richardson 7 Josh Downs 5 Peyton Manning 4 Alec Pierce 3 Reggie Wayne 3 Jonathan Taylor 2 Peyton Manning/Reggie Wayne 2 Adam Vinatieri 1 Adam Vinatieri/Alan Faneca/Dallas Clark/Hines Ward/Jeff Saturday/Jerome Bettis/Mike Vrabel/Peyton Manning/Reggie Wayne/Tedy Bruschi/Troy Polamalu/Ty Law 1 Anthony Richardson/Bijan Robinson/Devon Witherspoon/Jahmyr Gibbs/Jaxon Smith-Njigba/Puka Nacua/Rashee Rice/Tommy DeVito/Tyson Bagent 1 Edgerrin James 1 Evan Hull 1

Featured Indianapolis Colts Players

Anthony Richardson 9 Josh Downs 9 Peyton Manning 8 Jonathan Taylor 7 Michael Pittman Jr. 5 Reggie Wayne 5 Alec Pierce 3 Anthony Richardson/C.J. Stroud 2 Anthony Richardson/Josh Downs 2 Jeff Saturday 2 Peyton Manning/Reggie Wayne 2 Aaron Rodgers/Breece Hall/Davante Adams/Derrick Henry/Garrett Wilson/Isiah Pacheco/Ja'Marr Chase/James Cook/Joe Burrow/Josh Allen/Josh Jacobs/Justin Herbert/Keenan Allen/Lamar Jackson/Nico Collins/Odell Beckham Jr./Patrick Mahomes II/Raheem Mostert/Stefon Diggs/Travis Etienne Jr./Trevor Lawrence/Tua Tagovailoa/Tyreek Hill/Zack Moss 1

Top Indianapolis Colts SSPs & Case Hits

Filter this team to SSPs to surface its short prints and case hits.

Complete Indianapolis Colts Checklist

The full card-by-card Indianapolis Colts checklist for 2023 National Treasures is listed above — every player, set, parallel, and short print. Switch to All Cards for a flat, filterable list.

View Indianapolis Colts checklist ↑ Compare Indianapolis Colts players →

Indianapolis Colts FAQ

How many Indianapolis Colts cards are in 2023 National Treasures?

Savvy Collecting tracks 77 unique Indianapolis Colts cards (parallels collapsed) across 34 players in the 2023 National Treasures checklist, including base cards, inserts, parallels, short prints, and autographs.

How many Indianapolis Colts rookie cards are in 2023 National Treasures?

There are 29 Indianapolis Colts rookie cards in the 2023 National Treasures checklist tracked here, highlighted in purple.

Which Indianapolis Colts players have autographs in 2023 National Treasures?

Indianapolis Colts autograph signers include Anthony Richardson, Josh Downs, Peyton Manning, Alec Pierce, Reggie Wayne, and Jonathan Taylor. Filter the team to autographs to see every signed card.

How do I compare Indianapolis Colts players?

Use the Compare Players tool to line up any two players side by side across products and years — checklist depth, autographs, and short prints — to judge break value.