Skip to content
Savvy Collecting Savvy Collecting
Football

Indianapolis Colts — 2025 Certified Checklist

Browse by team or search a player, card number, or set. Use Autos and SSPs to narrow the checklist.

Product overview & checklist counts

The Indianapolis Colts have 31 unique cards in 2025 Certified Football across 19 players. Tyler Warren leads the team with 5 cards, followed by Riley Leonard with 4. The Colts checklist includes 10 autograph subjects, 4 rookies, and cards from 201 distinct card sets. SSP short prints are tracked for Tyler Warren.

Indianapolis Colts Overview

The 2025 Certified Indianapolis Colts checklist tracked on Savvy Collecting spans 31 unique cards (parallels collapsed), 19 players, 12 rookie cards, 14 autographs, and 1 short prints. Below you'll find every Indianapolis Colts player, their rookie cards, autographs, and short prints (SSPs) — plus the complete card-by-card checklist for the team.

Notable Indianapolis Colts autograph signers in 2025 Certified include Tyler Warren, Adonai Mitchell, Riley Leonard, Antoine Bethea, and DJ Giddens. Filter the checklist to autographs to see every signed Indianapolis Colts card.

On the chase side, the scarcest Indianapolis Colts cards come from short-printed sets such as First Round Certifications.

The most-collected Indianapolis Colts players in this product are Tyler Warren, Riley Leonard, Adonai Mitchell, Anthony Richardson, and DJ Giddens. Open any player to see their full card list, or use the player comparison tool to weigh two Indianapolis Colts players side by side.

31Unique Cards
365Cards
19Players
12Rookie Cards
14Autographs
1SSP Cards
201Card Sets
When both are active, shows cards with autographs or SSP versions. –
About filters & checklist counts

Choose a team or school to browse its cards. All Cards groups cards by family. Counts show unique card identities with parallels collapsed; shared cards count once in product totals.

Indianapolis Colts 31

31 unique cards · 365 appearances including parallels Team page →

Adonai Mitchell

2 unique cards · 18 versions
  • 8 Adonai MitchellIndianapolis Colts Certified Potential Signatures Includes Auto
  • 58 Adonai MitchellIndianapolis Colts Mirror Signatures · Mirror Signatures Lime Green Includes Auto

Anthony Richardson

2 unique cards · 25 versions
  • 42 Anthony RichardsonIndianapolis Colts Base
  • 1 Anthony RichardsonIndianapolis Colts Materials Mirror Red Etch

Antoine Bethea

1 unique card · 9 versions
  • 59 Antoine BetheaIndianapolis Colts Mirror Signatures · Mirror Signatures Lime Green Includes Auto

DeForest Buckner

1 unique card · 11 versions
  • 17 DeForest BucknerIndianapolis Colts Franchise Foundations · Franchise Foundations Mirror · Franchise Foundations Mirror Lime Green

DJ Giddens

2 unique cards · 30 versions
  • 1 DJ GiddensIndianapolis Colts Rookie Signatures Includes Auto
  • 164 DJ GiddensIndianapolis Colts Rookies

Edgerrin James

2 unique cards · 15 versions
  • 12 Edgerrin JamesIndianapolis Colts Immortals · Immortals Mirror · Immortals Mirror Lime Green
  • 5 Edgerrin JamesIndianapolis Colts Pro Materials Signatures · Pro Materials Signatures Lime Green Includes Auto

Eric Dickerson

1 unique card · 1 version
  • 6 Eric DickersonIndianapolis Colts Canton Certified Signatures Black Etch Includes Auto

Jeff Saturday

1 unique card · 7 versions
  • 9 Jeff SaturdayIndianapolis Colts Piece of the Game Signatures · Piece of the Game Signatures Lime Green Includes Auto

Jonathan Taylor

2 unique cards · 28 versions
  • 43 Jonathan TaylorIndianapolis Colts Base
  • 12 Jonathan TaylorIndianapolis Colts Certified Stars · Certified Stars Mirror · Certified Stars Mirror Lime Green

Josh Downs

1 unique card · 17 versions
  • 44 Josh DownsIndianapolis Colts Base

JT Tuimoloau

1 unique card · 17 versions
  • 194 JT TuimoloauIndianapolis Colts Rookies

Michael Pittman Jr.

1 unique card · 7 versions
  • 12 Michael Pittman Jr.Indianapolis Colts Piece of the Game · Piece of the Game Lime Green

Peyton Manning

1 unique card · 11 versions
  • 18 Peyton ManningIndianapolis Colts Immortals · Immortals Mirror · Immortals Mirror Lime Green

Riley Leonard

4 unique cards · 59 versions
  • 33 Riley LeonardIndianapolis Colts Freshman Fabric Mirror Signatures Includes Auto
  • 30 Riley LeonardIndianapolis Colts New Generation Jerseys Mirror · New Generation Jerseys Mirror Lime Green
  • 16 Riley LeonardIndianapolis Colts Rookie Signatures Includes Auto
  • 137 Riley LeonardIndianapolis Colts Rookies

Riley Leonard/Peyton Manning

1 unique card · 8 versions
  • 6 Riley Leonard/Peyton ManningIndianapolis Colts Stitches in Time Dual Mirror Red Etch

Robert Mathis

1 unique card · 5 versions
  • 10 Robert MathisIndianapolis Colts Pro Materials Signatures · Pro Materials Signatures Lime Green Includes Auto

Ryan Kelly

1 unique card · 5 versions
  • 60 Ryan KellyIndianapolis Colts Mirror Signatures · Mirror Signatures Lime Green Includes Auto

Tyler Warren

5 unique cards · 84 versions
  • 12 Tyler WarrenIndianapolis Colts Certified Rookies · Certified Rookies Mirror · Certified Rookies Mirror Lime Green
  • 7 Tyler WarrenIndianapolis Colts First Round Certifications Includes Auto Includes SSP
  • 41 Tyler WarrenIndianapolis Colts New Generation Jerseys Mirror Includes Auto
  • 15 Tyler WarrenIndianapolis Colts Rookie Signatures Includes Auto
  • 113 Tyler WarrenIndianapolis Colts Rookies

Tyler Warren/Colston Loveland/Elijah Arroyo/Terrance Ferguson

1 unique card · 8 versions
  • 4 Tyler Warren/Colston Loveland/Elijah Arroyo/Terrance FergusonChicago Bears · Indianapolis Colts · Los Angeles Rams · Seattle Seahawks Stitches in Time Quad Mirror Red Etch

Indianapolis Colts Rookies

Tyler Warren 5 Riley Leonard 4 DJ Giddens 2 JT Tuimoloau 1

Top Indianapolis Colts SSPs & Case Hits

Complete Indianapolis Colts Checklist

The full card-by-card Indianapolis Colts checklist for 2025 Certified is listed above — every player, set, parallel, and short print. Switch to All Cards for a flat, filterable list.

View Indianapolis Colts checklist ↑ Compare Indianapolis Colts players →

Indianapolis Colts FAQ

How many Indianapolis Colts cards are in 2025 Certified?

Savvy Collecting tracks 31 unique Indianapolis Colts cards (parallels collapsed) across 19 players in the 2025 Certified checklist, including base cards, inserts, parallels, short prints, and autographs.

How many Indianapolis Colts rookie cards are in 2025 Certified?

There are 12 Indianapolis Colts rookie cards in the 2025 Certified checklist tracked here, highlighted in purple.

Which Indianapolis Colts players have autographs in 2025 Certified?

Indianapolis Colts autograph signers include Tyler Warren, Adonai Mitchell, Riley Leonard, Antoine Bethea, DJ Giddens, and Edgerrin James. Filter the team to autographs to see every signed card.

What are the Indianapolis Colts SSPs and short prints in 2025 Certified?

The scarcest Indianapolis Colts short prints in 2025 Certified come from sets such as First Round Certifications.

How do I compare Indianapolis Colts players?

Use the Compare Players tool to line up any two players side by side across products and years — checklist depth, autographs, and short prints — to judge break value.